New York appeals court overturns rape conviction against Harvey Weinstein

The Court of Appeal believes that the judge was biased in the ground-breaking case in 2020, in which Weinstein was sentenced to 23 years in prison.

The court also believes that the judge made many mistakes, such as allowing women to testify about issues that were not part of the case. The court has ordered a new trial against Weinstein.

The judge in the original case compounded the misconduct by allowing cross-examination that portrayed Weinstein in a “grossly prejudicial light,” according to Thursday’s ruling.

– The only way to correct these gross errors is to hold a new trial, it says.

23 years in prison

The decision to overturn the rape conviction was made by four to three votes in the Court of Appeal. The court concluded that Weinstein did not receive fair treatment.

In the case in 2020, the 72-year-old film producer was convicted of rape and sexual assault against two women.

The article continues below the adThe article continues below the ad

Weinstein’s lawyer Arthur Aidala tells The New York Times that Thursday’s decision is a victory.

– We praise the Court of Appeal for safeguarding the most basic principles that a defendant must have in a trial, he says.

No free man

In a separate case, Weinstein was sentenced to 16 years in prison in California last year for the rape of an actor in Los Angeles in 2013. This sentence has not been overturned, and the film producer therefore remains behind bars.

At the time, Weinstein was considered to be among Hollywood’s most powerful men, and the accusations against him were the starting point for the MeToo movement.

The article continues below the adThe article continues below the ad

It began in 2017 with an article in The New York Times, where a number of women came forward and accused Weinstein of sexual harassment, assault and rape.

In the time that followed, women from all over the world came forward with stories of sexual abuse and abuse. As a result of divisions and whistle-blowing cases, a number of high-profile male actors, producers, business leaders and politicians had to resign from their jobs and positions.

Thursday’s sensational turnaround reopens a painful chapter in America’s reckoning with sexual abuse by powerful people. Many women may have to relive their traumas in the witness box.